Skip to main content
Qadyanis

Bhkhari Corrupted Argument

1 min read 109 words

Qadiani claim of Muslims altering Sahih Al-Bukhari proves that they know nothing about Hadith.

Sahih Al-Bukhari as a book has different chains of narration to Imam Al-Bukhari. Some of these chains have differences, one of them is the different wordings of this Hadith.

GP3yO7nWYAEKHxO a5597a3620ccf06a
GP3yO7nWYAEKHxO a5597a3620ccf06a

GP3yNS1WwAAWryx e82ee8c47a6255e4
GP3yNS1WwAAWryx e82ee8c47a6255e4

GP3yNS1WwAAWryx 848958b9abfe752d
GP3yNS1WwAAWryx 848958b9abfe752d

In this detailed print you can see يضع الجزية is used and يضع الحرب is mentioned as a variant wording with the narrators who used it.

Ibn Hajar also mentioned both wordings in his commentary on Sahih Al-Bukhari.

This Hadith is also in Sahih Muslim and يضع الجزية is used.

GP3yvd WIAAPy6X 47e97d53836d424f
GP3yvd WIAAPy6X 47e97d53836d424f

GP3yuBJWcAAqlnu e74c8f5bb82f82c0
GP3yuBJWcAAqlnu e74c8f5bb82f82c0

GP3yrnNWwAAM Zs 0dac22bb2f347bf5
GP3yrnNWwAAM Zs 0dac22bb2f347bf5

GP3yqDiWYAAzbnn e814d4f89816c6db
GP3yqDiWYAAzbnn e814d4f89816c6db

Both wordings are used together in another narration in Musnad Ahmad

“وتوضع الجزية وتضع الحرب أوزارها

GP3y9KBWcAEfT 6 e04b657a7855ffeb
GP3y9KBWcAEfT 6 e04b657a7855ffeb