Did Paul Teach That Christ Is the Creator? A Refutation of the Misuse of Colossians 1:16
Did Paul Teach That Christ Is the Creator? A Refutation of the Misuse of Colossians 1:16
- The Christian Claim From Colossians 1 16
- Theological Error
- Correct Understanding
- Psalm 51 10 and Spiritual Creation
- 2 Corinthians 5 17 and the New Creation
- Ephesians 4 24 and the New Man
- Christ as the Firstborn of All Creation
- Only God Is the Creator of Heaven and Earth
- Whispers in Your Ear My Christian Friend
- Paul’s Call in Acts 14
- Romans 1 25 and Worshipping the Creature
- References
- Additional Note on Ephesians 3 9
- The Textual Variant Through Jesus Christ
- Arabic Translations and Ancient Versions
- Final Comparison With Arius
The Christian Claim From Colossians 1 16
“For in him all things were created, that are in heaven and that are on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or principalities or powers — all things were created through him and for him.”
They adhere to the literal meaning of the text and say that the text says “all things were created through Him and for Him.” They even go so far as to say that what is meant here is that Christ is the Creator..!!
Theological Error
In fact, we know that Paul never claimed the divinity of Christ or the Trinity, nor did he call for the worship of Christ.
But I want to ask my Christian friend:
The text says everything through Him. Was He created through Christ, or is He the Creator?
It is absolutely not permissible for me to say that God was created through Him, but rather I say that God is the Creator of everything.
If we take the text literally like this, we would find that Christ was created through Him, that is, He was an instrument of creation, and this is not permissible with regard to God.
Correct Understanding
We say that the creation intended in the text is the creation of faith and not the true creation.
What confirms my words are many texts, including:
— Psalms 51:10
We find that the text here does not speak about the true creation, but rather speaks about the creation of faith and spiritual creation.
What confirms my words is the applied interpretation when it says:

This Arabic scan is from an Arabic Christian commentary discussing Psalm 51:10, where David says:“Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a steadfast spirit within me.” The explanation says that David is not asking God to physically create a new organ inside him. Rather, the meaning is spiritual: David asks God for a purified heart, a renewed inner spirit, and moral cleansing after sin. The highlighted/central point is that the word “create” can be used in a spiritual and moral sense, not only in the sense of literal material creation. This supports the argument that biblical language about “creation” can refer to a new spiritual state, a purified heart, or renewal of faith.
This is the required part of the interpretation:

This Arabic scan explains Psalm 51:10 more directly. It says that when David asks God to“create” in him a pure heart, he is not speaking about physical creation. The commentary explains that David is asking for purity, inward renewal, and a heart cleansed from sins and evil thoughts. The important point is that the text itself uses the word “create” for spiritual renewal, not literal creation from nothing. This is why the author uses this scan to argue that “creation” language in Christian scripture does not automatically mean real cosmic creation.
Here we find that he says ask God to create in you a pure heart and a pure mind. It does not mean the real creation, but rather the spiritual or faith creation.
2 Corinthians 5 17 and the New Creation
Also, this text proves and confirms what we say:
— 2 Corinthians 5:17
So the new creation is not a real creation, but rather a creation of faith and spirit.
So when some say that today I have been created anew or born again, that does not mean that he has really been created.
Also, what clarifies the meaning of the creation of faith is the applied interpretation:

This Arabic scan comments on 2 Corinthians 5:17:“If anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation.” The commentary explains that believers appear with a new life, while people around them may not understand this transformation. It describes this as an inner change produced by union with Christ: a new heart, new status, and new way of life. The scan does not interpret “new creation” as literal physical creation. It explains it as a spiritual and religious transformation. This supports the argument that “creation” in such Pauline passages can mean renewal of faith and spiritual life.
And also Father Antonius Fikry says:

This Arabic scan from Father Antonius Fikry’s commentary explains 2 Corinthians 5:17. He says that whoever is in Christ is anew creation, because old things have passed away and everything has become new. He explains this through Christian theological language: the believer has died with Christ, buried the old sinful life in baptism, and risen into a new life. The explanation focuses on moral and spiritual renewal, not physical creation. The scan therefore confirms that Christian commentators themselves understand “new creation” in this verse as spiritual transformation.
This is also what the modern interpretation of the Holy Bible confirmed:

This Arabic scan fromThe Modern Interpretation of the Holy Bible explains the phrase “all things have become new” in 2 Corinthians 5:17. It says that the phrase does not mean the physical universe has changed, because the old order still remains visible around us. Rather, Paul means that for the person who is in Christ, a new order has begun because he has entered a new relationship and a new reality. The highlighted sentence says: “The human person is renewed by the spirit of God; he is a new creation.” The commentary then explains that the new creation is connected to reconciliation, moral renewal, and the new relationship with God. This scan is important because it directly confirms that “new creation” is understood spiritually by Christian commentators, not as literal material creation.
Christ was created through him, but he created faith and created the spirit, not the real creation…!
Ephesians 4 24 and the New Man
Also, what confirms the spiritual creation or the creation of holiness is the following text:
— The Epistle to the Ephesians 4:24
Thus, you find all the texts explain to us that Christ was created with it, but not the real creation, but the spiritual and faith-based creation.
Therefore, the meaning of the text proves that Christ is only a messenger.
When he calls people to worship the one God, he saves them from their sins… so they are as if they were created anew and born again, as the previous texts explained.
So why do the ignorant claim that the text proves that Christ was created with a real creation in its literal sense?
God was not created by Him, but we say that God is the Creator and not a tool by which He is created…
Christ as the Firstborn of All Creation
In fact, if you go back a little from this text that proves the creation of faith or spiritual creation, you will find that Christ is a creature:
“Who is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation.”
The text here says that Christ is in the image of God, and of course we all know that Adam is in the image of God, just like Christ…
What is useful is that the word firstborn of all creation means the first creature or the firstborn of all creatures of his kind, and of course we all know that Christ was created without a father and Eve is the firstborn of all creatures of her kind because she was created without a mother, so the text proves that Christ is the firstborn of all creatures of his kind.
Whoever reads these texts will cut a text and try to prove that Christ was created by Him, and this is a mistake…
Only God Is the Creator of Heaven and Earth
We say that the only one worthy of worship is God, for He is the Creator of the heavens and the earth:
— Revelation 10:6
Whispers in Your Ear My Christian Friend
Look at what Paul was calling for.
Gods do not incarnate, worship the Creator of heaven and earth!
Paul’s Call in Acts 14
“And there was sitting in Lystra a man who was impotent in his feet, a cripple from his mother’s womb, who had never walked.
(9) This man was listening to Paul speaking. And he, looking intently at him, and seeing that he had faith to be healed,
(10) said with a loud voice, ‘Stand upright on your feet.’ And he leaped up and began to walk.
(11) And when the crowds saw what Paul had done, they lifted up their voices in the Lycaonian language, saying, ‘The gods have come down to us in the likeness of men.’
(12) And they called Barnabas Zeus, and Paul Hermes, because he was the chief speaker.
(13) And the priest of Zeus, who was before the city, brought bulls and wreaths to the gates with the crowds, and he wanted to sacrifice.
(14) But when the apostles Barnabas and Paul heard this, they tore their clothes and rushed into the crowd, crying out,
(15) ‘Men, why are you doing these things? We also are men with like passions as you. We bring you good news that you should turn from these vanities to the living God, who made heaven and earth and sea and all that is in them.’
(16)”
An explicit call to worship the One who created the heavens and reject the incarnation. !!
Paul, despite his misleading and distorting Christianity, never called for the worship of Christ, but rather called for the worship of the living God, Lord of the heavens and the earth, the God of Christ, peace be upon him.
Thus, you did not find a single text proving that Christ created an ant in the Holy Bible.
So how do you worship the creature and abandon the Creator?
Romans 1 25 and Worshipping the Creature
I will only say one word to you:
— The Epistle to the Romans 1:25
Muadh Alyan
References
(2) The Applied Interpretation - by a group of Christian scholars and theologians - page 2474.
(3) Interpretation of the Second Epistle to the Corinthians - by Father Antonious Fikry - page 47.
(4) The Modern Interpretation of the Holy Bible - The Second Epistle to the Corinthians - Editor-in-Chief Joseph Saber - page 104.
Additional Note on Ephesians 3 9
I add what Paul said:
— Ephesians 3:9
The Textual Variant Through Jesus Christ
The fingers of distortion refuse to leave the texts as they are!
The phrase “through Jesus Christ” does not exist in the Alexandrian Greek version, nor the Latin Vulgate, nor the Syriac Peshitta!!
Arabic Translations and Ancient Versions
τω θεω τω τα παντα κτισαντι
ــــ: God who created all things.
This is the text adopted by the Nestle-Aland NOVUM TESTAMENTUM version, which was adopted by the Arabic Christian Electronic Encyclopedia, and it does not have this addition!
Deo qui omnia creavit
ـــــ: God who created all.
ܐܠܗܐ ܕܟܠ ܒܪܐ
ـــــ: God who created all.
God is the creator of all things.
God is the creator of all things.
God is the creator of all things.
God is the creator of all things.
Look at the Arabic translations, they unanimously agreed to drop this addition, and the Copts still adhere to Van Dyck’s translation!
Paul did not apply the description of Creator to anyone except God, and it was difficult for the distorters to have Paul say this without referring to Christ.
Despite this distorted addition, its authors did not include Christ under the description Creator, but the most they did was consider him an intermediary in creation!
Final Comparison With Arius
- Creator
- Creature
And Christ is not the Creator, then what logic says that He is not a creature!
Compare this with the ancient opinion of Arius who considered Christ a creature and an intermediary in creation as well!