Skip to main content
Refuting Claimz

Get Tabook for Yellow Girls

2 min read 334 words

The first isnad

cl81 0cec994cd66b1031
cl81 0cec994cd66b1031

It says mujahid said But did mujahid meet the prophet ?

Translation: “Mujahid bin jabr died 101,102.,103,104 when he was 83 years old”

-Source: Takrib al-tahzib page number 453 ibn hajar (RH) person number 6481 by name mujahid bin jabr

So lets take the most recent year 101

101-83=18 A.H The prophet died 11 A.H as all Muslims know that makes the hadith mursal and weak

Narration number #2

cl83 225de5177de8e6ae
cl83 225de5177de8e6ae

There is also a problem here Ibn jarij if he said kal the hadith automatically is da’if

Translation: “Narrated Ahmed bin Hanbal: if ibn jarij said Kal or Kal fulan came with rejected narrations”

-Source: Syar aalam al-nubalaa volume 6 page number 328

cl84 42451322840eb91a
cl84 42451322840eb91a

isnad number #3

cl85 a8dfba16aef58667
cl85 a8dfba16aef58667

The hadith contains ibn humaid who is he

Translation: “It has been proven to us that ibn hamid is a liar”

-Source: Al-Majroohin Min al-muhadetheen imam bin haban (RH) volume 2 page number 321 person number 1005 by name “muhammed bin humaid Al-Razy” end of the page

cl86 0327bcd9c33a45c0
cl86 0327bcd9c33a45c0

None of the first narrators met the prophet again a mursal hadith

Narration number #4

cl88 3ff30e358edfba71
cl88 3ff30e358edfba71

cl87 6ba6d6c2c70633ae
cl87 6ba6d6c2c70633ae

Ibn zayd wasn’t alive at the time of the prophet

And he is weak

Translation: “Abdulrahman bin zayd bin aslam is a weak narrator”

-Source: Takrib al-Tahzib bin hajar al-Asqualani (RH) page number 282 person number 3865

cl89 a83b842f461bc716
cl89 a83b842f461bc716

Narration number #5

cl8a 6c5b7dd7c90f95b0
cl8a 6c5b7dd7c90f95b0

This narration contains “Yehia bin abdulhamid” is he a weak narrator?

Translation: “Yehia bin Abdulhamid is munkar al-hadith Nisa’i said Da’if in hadith (weak narrator) and ahmed said (He lied too much)”

-Source: Al-Mughny fi al-Duafaa Al-Dhahabi (RH) volume 2 page number 407 person number 7006 by name “Yehia bin Abdulhamid”

Narration number #6

cl8c 679f6649b6c3873d
cl8c 679f6649b6c3873d

This hadith contains Jabara bin Al-Mughlis is he weak ?

Translation: “Al-Bukhari said: Disorted in hadith Ibn maain said : He is a liar

Ibn namir said he puts hadith from his own without knowing”

-Source: Syar aalam al-Nubalaa volume 11 page number 151 person number 57 by name “Jabara bin Al-Mughalis” by Al-Dhahabi (RH)

cl8d 99f2d34ba807f409
cl8d 99f2d34ba807f409

Conclusion: All narration are daif🤷‍♂️