Skip to main content
Refutations

The Story of Safiyya bint Huyayy — Mother of the Believers, Not a Captive Taken by Force

12 min read 2503 words
The Prophet ﷺ Killed Safiyya’s Husband and Father and Then Married Her by Force Critics claim that the Prophet ﷺ assaulted Safiyya bint Huyayy, using the facts that her husband and father were killed and that she came from among the captives as evidence of coercion.
The story of (RA) is recorded in full in the books of Islamic biography. Word thieves extracted three phrases — “killed her husband,” “killed her father,” “married her” — stripped them of their context, and replaced them with the word “assaulted.” The full account from those same books of biography establishes: she was a free woman of noble lineage who chose Islam, was given an explicit choice between freedom and marriage, chose marriage of her own will, and spent the rest of her life as a devoted Mother of the Believers. Those who raise this doubt are invited to read the entire story.

First — Her Lineage

Safiyya bint Huyayy ibn Akhtab ibn Sa’na was not an ordinary captive. Her father was the master of Banu Nadir, from the tribe of Levi, son of the Prophet of God Israel (Jacob), son of Isaac, son of Abraham (peace be upon them all). She came from the most distinguished lineage among the People of the Book.

Second — The Prophet ﷺ Did Not Order the Killing of Banu Qurayza

The Jews of Banu Qurayza betrayed their covenant with the Muslims during the Battle of the Trench, while the Muslims were engaged against the polytheists. Ali ibn Abi Talib (RA) advanced on the fortress calling out: “O battalion of faith!” and al-Zubayr ibn al-Awwam (RA) said: “By God, I will taste what Hamza tasted or I will conquer their fortress.”

Then the Jews of Banu Qurayza themselves called out: “O Muhammad, we will submit to the judgment of Sa’d ibn Mu’adh.” They chose Sa’d ibn Mu’adh (RA) — the leader of their allies the Aws — because they believed he would pardon them as the leader of the Khazraj had pardoned Banu Qaynuqa’. But God disappointed their expectations.

Sa’d ibn Mu’adh (RA) ruled that the fighting men be killed, the women and children taken captive, and the property divided. This ruling is present in the Torah before the revelation of the Gospel and the Quran — it is the ruling for those who betray a covenant and a pact. The Prophet ﷺ said of Sa’d’s judgment: “You have judged them according to the judgment of God from above the seven heavens.”

The Prophet ﷺ did not fight Banu Qurayza, nor did he order the killing of any of them. The one who ruled was Sa’d, and they were the ones who asked him to rule.

Third — The Ruling of the Old Testament on Traitors in Wartime

The parallel between Sa’d’s ruling and the Torah’s own command is precise:

1 Samuel 15:1–11 (ESV) “Samuel said to Saul, ‘I am the one whom the Lord sent to anoint you king over his people Israel. Now hear the words of the Lord. Thus says the Lord of hosts, I have noted what Amalek did to Israel in opposing them on the way when they came up out of Egypt. Now go and strike Amalek and devote to destruction all that they have. Do not spare them, but kill both man and woman, child and infant, ox and sheep, camel and donkey.’ So Saul summoned the people and numbered them in Telaim, two hundred thousand men on foot. And he came to the city of Amalek and lay in wait in the valley. And he said to the Kenites, ‘Go, depart; go down from among the Amalekites, lest I destroy you with them.’ So the Kenites departed from among the Amalekites. And Saul defeated the Amalekites from Havilah as far as Shur, which is east of Egypt. And he took Agag the king of the Amalekites alive and devoted to destruction all the people with the edge of the sword. But Saul and the people spared Agag and the best of the sheep and of the oxen and of the fattened calves and the lambs, and all that was good, and would not utterly destroy them. Then the word of the Lord came to Samuel: I regret that I have made Saul king, for he has turned back from following me and has not performed my commandments. And Samuel was angry, and he cried to the Lord all night.”

The comparison between the two cases:

The Amalekites betrayed Israel on the road out of Egypt — God commanded total destruction: men, women, children, infants, and animals. The Jews of Banu Qurayza betrayed the Muslims during active warfare — Sa’d ruled that only the fighting men be killed, while women and children were taken captive. The Islamic ruling was more merciful than the Torah’s own command.

Furthermore: God was angry with Saul because he spared the Amalekite king Agag. Sa’d did not spare Huyayy ibn Akhtab, the leader of Banu Qurayza — and the Prophet ﷺ confirmed this was the judgment of God.

The Jews of Banu Qurayza knew their fate from their own book. Ka’b ibn Asad told them: “By God it has become clear to you that he is a sent prophet.” He offered them three options, one of which was to believe in the Messenger. They said: “We will never depart from the rulings of the Torah.” When they asked Abu Lubabah: “Shall we submit to the ruling of Muhammad?” he pointed to his throat — they understood what the Torah’s own ruling demanded. A woman from Banu Qurayza who was with Aisha (RA) — laughing outwardly and inwardly — when her name was called, told Aisha: “I will be killed” — because she had killed a Muslim man by treachery before the siege. They knew. They chose betrayal anyway.

Fourth — The Marriage Was Safiyya’s Free Choice

After the conquest of Khaybar, Safiyya (RA) was among the captives. The Prophet ﷺ gave her an explicit choice:

“Choose. If you choose Islam, I will keep you for myself — that is, I will marry you. If you choose Judaism, I may free you so that you may join your people.”

She responded:

“O Messenger of God, I loved Islam and believed in you before you called me, since I came to your camp. I have no interest in Judaism, nor do I have a father or a brother in it, and you gave me the choice between disbelief and Islam — so God and His Messenger are more beloved to me than freedom and returning to my people.”

She was not coerced. She was given the choice of freedom and she declined it.

The Sahih Muslim narration establishes that the Prophet ﷺ did not seek Safiyya out by name and did not know who she was:

Sahih Muslim 3563 — Book of Marriage Anas (RA) narrated: The Prophet of Allah ﷺ invaded Khaybar. We prayed the dawn prayer there in the early hours of the morning. The Prophet ﷺ rode and Abu Talhah rode and I was riding behind Abu Talhah. The Prophet ﷺ ran through the alleys of Khaybar and my knee was touching the thigh of the Prophet ﷺ, and the izar was pulled back from his thigh, and I saw the whiteness of the thigh of the Prophet ﷺ. When he entered the village, he said: “Allah is Greater, Khaybar has been destroyed. When we encamp in the courtyard of a people, evil is the morning for those who were warned.” He said it three times. The people had gone out to their work and they said: Muhammad — by Allah. We seized it by force and the captives were gathered. Dihya came to him and said: “O Messenger of Allah, give me a slave girl from the captives.” He said: “Go and take a slave girl.” So he took Safiyya bint Huyayy. Then a man came to the Prophet ﷺ and said: “O Prophet of Allah, you gave Dihya Safiyya bint Huyayy, the chief of Qurayza and al-Nadir — she is only suitable for you.” He said: “Call Dihya with her.” So he brought her, and when the Prophet ﷺ looked at her, he said to Dihya: “Take another slave girl from the captives.” And he freed her and married her. Thabit said to Anas: “O Abu Hamza, what was her dowry?” He said: “Her freedom — he freed her and married her.” Then when the Prophet ﷺ was on the road, Umm Sulaym prepared her for him and presented her to him during the night. The Prophet ﷺ became a bridegroom and said: “Whoever has something, let him bring it.” And he spread out a mat. A man would bring yoghurt, a man would bring dates, and a man would bring ghee, and they made a stew. That was the feast of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.

Grade: Sahih · Muslim

The Prophet ﷺ did not seek Safiyya out by name. He gave her to Dihya initially without even knowing who she was. He only retrieved her when a Companion informed him she was the daughter of the chief of Qurayza and al-Nadir. He then freed her and made her freedom her dowry.

When she came from Khaybar, she stayed in the house of Haritha ibn al-Nu’man. The women of the neighbourhood came to see her because of what they had heard of her beauty. Aisha (RA) also came — she was said to have been veiled. After she left, the Messenger of Allah ﷺ asked Aisha about Safiyya, and Aisha replied: “I saw a Jewish woman.” The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: “She has converted to Islam and her conversion is good.”

Umayya bint Abi Qais said: “I heard that she was not yet seventeen years old when she was married to the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.”

When the Prophet ﷺ offered to marry her, she initially declined, and this affected the noble Messenger ﷺ. They continued on their way to al-Sahba’. When the Prophet ﷺ later entered upon Safiyya and asked her about the reason for her earlier refusal of the wedding, she told him that she had feared for him because of the Jews’ proximity. She was not reluctant to be with him — she was protecting him.

Fifth — She Testified to His Prophethood Before Her Conversion

Ibn Ishaq records Safiyya’s own account of the moment she understood that the Prophet ﷺ was sent by God:

When the Prophet ﷺ arrived in Madinah and settled in Quba with Banu Amr ibn Awf, her father Huyayy ibn Akhtab and her uncle Abu Yasir ibn Akhtab went to him in the early hours of the morning. They did not return until sunset — tired, slumped, and walking slowly. She had been the most beloved child of her father and uncle, but neither turned to look at her despite the grief they were in. She heard her uncle Abu Yasir say to her father: “Is he he?” Her father said: “Yes, by God.” Her uncle said: “Do you recognise him and confirm him?” Her father said: “Yes.” Her uncle said: “What is in your heart towards him?” Her father said: “His enmity, by God, for as long as I remain.”

Her father confirmed the prophethood of Muhammad ﷺ with his own mouth — and chose enmity anyway. Safiyya (RA) chose differently.

Sixth — Her Life as Mother of the Believers

Ibn Hajar in Al-Isaba and Ibn Sa’d in Al-Tabaqat record, on the authority of Zayd ibn Aslam (RA):

During the final illness of the Prophet ﷺ, his wives gathered around him. Safiyya said: “By God, O Prophet of God, I wish that what you have were in me instead of you.” His other wives exchanged glances of doubt at her words. He said: “By God, she is telling the truth.”

When some of his wives said to her that they were better than her because they were daughters of his paternal uncle and his wives, the Prophet ﷺ guided her to respond: “Why did you not say: How can you two be better than me? My husband is Muhammad, my father is Aaron, and my uncle is Moses.”

During the caliphate of Umar ibn al-Khattab (RA), a slave girl of hers came to Umar and said: Safiyya loves the Sabbath and maintains ties with the Jews. Umar sent for Safiyya and asked her. She replied: “As for the Sabbath, I have not loved it since God replaced it with Friday. As for the Jews, I have a kinship with them and I maintain ties with them.” Then she asked the slave girl: “What made you do what you did?” The girl said: “The devil.” Safiyya said: “Go — you are free.”

Seventh — Her Dream and What It Meant

On her wedding night with Kinanah ibn al-Rabi’, Safiyya saw in a dream that a moon fell into her lap. She told her husband about it, and he struck her on the face in anger, saying: “It is as if you wish for Muhammad, the king of Hijaz.” She came to the Prophet ﷺ with the mark of that blow on her face.

Conclusion — Four Points That Cannot Be Disputed

From all of the above, four points are established beyond doubt:

1. The Messenger ﷺ did not fight or order the killing of anyone from Banu Qurayza. The one who ruled was Sa’d ibn Mu’adh, and they were the ones who asked for him.

2. The one who ordered their killing was Sa’d ibn Mu’adh (RA), and their fate was prescribed in their own Torah before the Quran was revealed.

3. The Jews of Banu Qurayza knew their fate through their own book — but thought Sa’d would pardon them.

4. The marriage of the Mother of the Believers Safiyya (RA) was by her own desire. She was given a free choice and she chose Islam and the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.

Safiyya bint Huyayy (RA) was the daughter of the master of Banu Nadir, from the lineage of the Prophets of Israel. She was given a free and explicit choice between freedom and marriage and chose marriage. She testified to the Prophet’s prophethood from her own father’s lips before she ever converted. Her dowry was her freedom. She was not yet seventeen years old. She spent the rest of her life defending him, loving him, and wishing his illness were hers. She freed a slave girl who betrayed her to the Caliph rather than punishing her. She died of grief — but not the grief her enemies imagine. She is the Mother of the Believers, and the enemies of Islam took three words from her story, discarded everything else, and called it evidence.

Safiyya bint Huyayy — The Distorted Word, the Biblical Double Standard, and Her Own Testimony

2024 https://www.openislam.wiki/og/the-story-of-safiyya-bint-huyayy-mother-of-the-believers-not-a-captive-taken-by-force.png