Skip to main content
Qadyanis

Double Eclipse Narration

1 min read 124 words

The double eclipse narration in Sunan Ad-Daraqutni is not just weak by Sunni standards of Hadith, it’s even weak by Shi’i standards.

GLEQaCiWkAAmZS2 e558966a0d7fa17c
GLEQaCiWkAAmZS2 e558966a0d7fa17c

GLEQaDBXIAAlHKU 34154774b8b66f0b
GLEQaDBXIAAlHKU 34154774b8b66f0b

GLEQaB WcAAUl0  7789c92e90ffdfca
GLEQaB WcAAUl0 7789c92e90ffdfca

GLEQaBgXkAAt1Cf 86f405c60cae9749
GLEQaBgXkAAt1Cf 86f405c60cae9749

They claim that the word قمر can’t be used for the moon in the first (or the last) days of the lunar month and it can only be called هلال.

Here are some examples of muhaddithin and MGA himself using قمر for the moon in the first and the last days of the lunar month.

GK9sPjkWAAEnBU  dd0cb73470c564f5
GK9sPjkWAAEnBU dd0cb73470c564f5

GK9sPjuXcAA908Q c877f9b9ed4e92b5
GK9sPjuXcAA908Q c877f9b9ed4e92b5

GK9sKOqWUAAatpI 4ca64ccf40f6e89f
GK9sKOqWUAAatpI 4ca64ccf40f6e89f

GK9sKOpWQAAgFyz f505df8433e9033a
GK9sKOpWQAAgFyz f505df8433e9033a

And since Qadianis don’t care about the authenticity,here is a narration from Muhammad Al-Baqir about this eclipse where he was told that the lunar eclipses only happen in the middle of the month, his response was that it will be a miraculous event unlike the usual eclipses.

GK9s4HJXcAAF5r  5cb5cee9c6dfd138
GK9s4HJXcAAF5r 5cb5cee9c6dfd138